January 23 Recordings and Chat Transcript

- George S joined the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
- mathteacher1729 joined the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
George S
3:05 PM
mic is yours Ashwin
but not hearing anything
3:05 PM
ok, hearing now
3:05 PM
yes
3:05 PM
Stephen Downes
3:05 PM
we hear you
Hua Ai
3:05 PM
yes
Preetha
3:05 PM
Can hear you
- lordonezv joined the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
- brainysmurf joined the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
Rich DeMillo
3:07 PM
the scale is important
George S
3:07 PM
they should be able to do that
I mean, it's only 37k
3:08 PM
Rich DeMillo
3:08 PM
not without breaking rules
- dean florez joined the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
Rich DeMillo
3:08 PM
sure
Preetha
3:08 PM
or the bank
George S
3:08 PM
@Preetha
Asad Choudhary #2
3:08 PM
Are we going to get a copy of the slideshow?
Mike McCracken
3:09 PM
alread posted on the MOOC site
Asad Choudhary #2
3:09 PM
Ok thanks
Hua Ai
3:09 PM
right here: http://gtmooc.files.wordpress.com/2012/01/web-concepts.pdf
mathteacher1729
3:10 PM
Thank you Hua.
Hua Ai
3:10 PM
welcome
brainysmurf
3:10 PM
that's a lot of iPads if one each
- beryl@20mm joined the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
- dalit joined the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
Matt
3:11 PM
iPads are consumer devices. Not much good for contributing
We need general purpose devices
3:11 PM
Rich DeMillo
3:11 PM
yes...accelerating demand
brainysmurf
3:11 PM
Thanks @Matt - what are best contributing devices do you think?
George S
3:11 PM
@Matt - really? I haven't found that to be the case. They can be very good for creating (at least looking at waht my kids do)
Matt
3:12 PM
Tablets are more limited than other devices in terms of file support and input devices
Rich DeMillo
3:12 PM
i dont' wan to dwell on doomsday predictions buyt...
George S
3:12 PM
doomsday can be fun, go with it
mathteacher1729
3:13 PM
Does this new-universities-needed account for the need for trade and vocational training?
In other words 37,000 academic universities or... 37,000 academic PLUS (trade , vocational schools).
3:13 PM
Matt
3:13 PM
Apprenticeships?
Ashwin Ram
3:14 PM
"More than one-third of the world’s population is under 20. To meet this staggering demand, a major university needs to be created each week." — Sir John Daniel (1996)
George S
3:15 PM
so many examples of this type of error
i.e. Kodak last week
3:15 PM
mathteacher1729
3:15 PM
What about trade / vocational schools? Are those included in the count of new universities?
brainysmurf
3:15 PM
@george S kodak last wk?
George S
3:15 PM
@brainysmurf: http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/01/19/us-kodak-idUSTRE80I08G20120119
- JGA joined the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
Rich DeMillo
3:16 PM
scale...scale...scale....
Matt
3:16 PM
Amazon made catalogue shopping easier, more convenient and quicker.
Rich DeMillo
3:16 PM
right
mass personalization
3:16 PM
Matt
3:17 PM
eBay introduced consumer ratings on a comprehensive, context based system.
Rich DeMillo
3:17 PM
reputation?
new studies of grade inflation support that...
3:17 PM
Matt
3:17 PM
It levels the playing field
brainysmurf
3:17 PM
@george s thx that's wild about Kodak. Talk about missing the boat!
Matt
3:18 PM
Small traders can build excellent reputations
brainysmurf
3:18 PM
big kids like to be part of networks too
dean florez
3:18 PM
could someone please send me the Gates study that was just cited? graduation rates? dean@20mm.org
Ashwin Ram
3:19 PM
"88% of high school dropouts have passing grades." Gates Foundation study “Silent Epidemic” (2006)
Preetha
3:19 PM
Dean, I can look for it and email you.
George S
3:19 PM
btw - Rich has a new book out - highly rated in all reviews I've seen: http://www.amazon.com/Abelard-Apple-American-Colleges-Universities/dp/0262015803/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1327346350&sr=8-1
Matt
3:20 PM
Traditional education systems are based on conformity and compliance.
i.e. make everyone "average"
3:20 PM
Preetha
3:20 PM
Silent Epidemic study: http://www.ignitelearning.com/pdf/TheSilentEpidemic3-06FINAL.pdf
Ashwin Ram
3:21 PM
I have the cite and link to the Silent Epidemic study on this blog: http://cognitivecomputing.wordpress.com/2010/04/26/massively-multiplayer-online%E2%80%94learning/
Preetha
3:21 PM
@dean
Ashwin Ram
3:21 PM
[ref. #7]
mathteacher1729
3:21 PM
You can re-arrange the words along the x-asix to form a bell-shaped curve if you please.
dean florez
3:21 PM
that's preetha. appreciated.
Preetha
3:22 PM
@mathteacher, Hi Joe
brainysmurf
3:22 PM
@mathteacher good pt
George S
3:22 PM
another positive aspects of large networks is that people can form small network clusters (i.e. Reeds law)
i.e. while at some levels, we get hubs, in a large enough network, we can create smaller networks that don't reflect those patterns
3:23 PM
brainysmurf
3:23 PM
@george s - I like that flexibility depending on situation in which large/small #s of participants make sense
Rich DeMillo
3:24 PM
universities are organized around popularity...
mathteacher1729
3:24 PM
Thank you for clarifying Ashwin.
- Andreas Link joined the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
- Rohan joined the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
Matt
3:27 PM
They're highly centralised and commoditise their users as entertainment.
Rich DeMillo
3:27 PM
we will see this on wednesday
JGA
3:28 PM
So is the problem more of trusting the learner to articulate legitimate goals and course activities over planning an adequate number of courses that accomodate the student wants?
Preetha
3:28 PM
Hua and I will be talking about our case study!
Rich DeMillo
3:28 PM
yes...break down the idea of a course
Matt
3:28 PM
Faceboo Revenue US$ 4.27 billion (2011 est.)
We need decentralised networks.
3:29 PM
Mike McCracken
3:29 PM
I'm sorry but I'm offline for a bit. I also don't think my audio is working but will retry it when I rejoin.
Matt
3:29 PM
Crowds aren't wise!
Another word for crowd in mob.
3:30 PM
is mob
3:30 PM
Ashwin Ram
3:30 PM
Live session on Wednesday talking about Social Capital within educational "communities of practice" - by Preetha Ram (@preetharam) and Hua Ai (@walkmanhua)
brainysmurf
3:30 PM
@matt - I believe the crowds we choose to run with (in personal learning networks) might be quite wise
- Dan left the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
Matt
3:31 PM
It's based on consensus rather than meritocratic, systematic analysis.
Unpopular ideas get lost.
3:31 PM
brainysmurf
3:31 PM
@matt did you hear dave snowden last week on value of dissent? quite interesting...
Preetha
3:31 PM
When the crowd morphs into a community of practice, with leaders,mentors and novices, you move towards wisdom!
Very zen!
3:31 PM
Matt
3:31 PM
Yes
- HowardJ joined the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
siavogel
3:32 PM
I agree with @brainsmurfy about PLN as my crowd
brainysmurf
3:32 PM
@preetha i like that
- John Schinker left the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
Preetha
3:32 PM
@brainysmurf thanks. Hear us out on Wed!
brainysmurf
3:32 PM
@preetha sounds good - details?
Matt
3:32 PM
I'm a born dissenter!
brainysmurf
3:33 PM
@matt that's good and welcomed
George S
3:33 PM
@Rich - we had an interesting experience the first time we offered CCK. We were using a learning management system...but eventually moved to blogs instead of a central space
learners need to own their own data
3:33 PM
brainysmurf
3:33 PM
@georgeS agree - becoming owner of my data is important growth activity. scary for some, enchanting for others
Rich DeMillo
3:34 PM
@george i love that direction...lms is destructive
Stephen Downes
3:34 PM
way too busy
Matt
3:34 PM
Check out Diaspora* as an open, decentralised alternative to Facebook, Twitter, et al.
brainysmurf
3:34 PM
@stephen
Stephen Downes
3:34 PM
exactly
Rich DeMillo
3:34 PM
I am at Apple today talking about how technology is taking this...
brainysmurf
3:35 PM
Part of that overwhelmedness seems necessary evil to force people to find their own info/time mgt solutions no?
Matt
3:36 PM
LMS' can provide necessary constraints and facilitate Social Constructivism. It depends on the LMS and how it's used.
Seán Conlan
3:36 PM
Where does peer review sit in this new world?
Matt
3:36 PM
I use peer review a lot.
Rich DeMillo
3:36 PM
@Matt say more
brainysmurf
3:36 PM
@matt I'm becoming less fond of LMS because of the whole 'membership' idea. Internalized in LMS, knowledge is stifled not Googleable.
Matt
3:36 PM
Moodle has a peer review module
Rich DeMillo
3:37 PM
I am meeting with Sebastian
Matt
3:37 PM
that facilitates easy, systematic peer review with rubrics
Seán Conlan
3:37 PM
I meant peer review in blogging...and owning your own space
Matt
3:37 PM
it encourages learners to develop their analytical and critical thinking skills
brainysmurf
3:38 PM
@matt - perhaps learners are *recovering* analytical and critical thinking skills beaten out of them in traditional ed?
George S
3:38 PM
love that statement "wandering seminar"
Matt
3:39 PM
and learners don't get to choose who they review, therefore they are exposed to points of view they don't necessarily agree with and are forced to think differently.
mathteacher1729
3:39 PM
Erdos published more papers than any mathematician ever. Euler wrote the most PAGES of any mathematician ever.
brainysmurf
3:39 PM
@matt eek don't like being told who I have to review
mathteacher1729
3:39 PM
Erdos made mathematics a social activity. Awesome guy. I love his Erdos-isms. "Children = Epsilons".
Matt
3:40 PM
@brainy, we "should" seek out differences and opposition but all too often we don't
mathteacher1729
3:40 PM
"Moot scale"? Did I mis-hear or did that mean "moodle-scale"?
And Moodle-scale = "Your course managmeent systme of coice ... scale"
3:40 PM
Matt
3:42 PM
@brainy, that's the inherent stupidity of crowds.
Going with the consensus and avoiding conflict
3:42 PM
brainysmurf
3:43 PM
@matt I'm starting to see that - too many fluffy bunnies according to dave snowden
Matt
3:43 PM

We need constraints, I guess.
3:44 PM
brainysmurf
3:44 PM
for me, moocs are crowds of people who 'get it' and in that sense are a welcome change from the rest of my work.
Matt
3:44 PM
I guess we're wolves
brainysmurf
3:45 PM
@mathteacher - tried to google epsilon, still don't get what it means?
@matt eating fluffy bunnies for breakfast?
3:45 PM
George S
3:45 PM
I love the annotation and debate feature in PLoS
mathteacher1729
3:46 PM
The greek letter epsilon (it looks likea backwards "3" represents a "very small number" in calculus.
Matt
3:46 PM
I typically get ignored by the majority. People shy away from difficult questions.
brainysmurf
3:47 PM
@math thanks, that helps. I was thinking it was the symbol for sum, in which case children as sum of something was also interesting
Preetha
3:47 PM
Here is the link to how communities of practice can help the fluffy bunnies problem with crowds or improve the wisdom of crowds, http://bit.ly/sGWTfo
brainysmurf
3:48 PM
one of best things i've learned from moocs is that info overload isn't the problem - filter failure is.
Seán Conlan
3:48 PM
is geography becoming irrelevant?
Matt
3:49 PM
Thanks Preetha!
brainysmurf
3:49 PM
@sean it is irrelevant for me! with the right tools at hand now
Ashwin Ram
3:49 PM
From @PreethaRam's OCWC Global 2011 talk: "Leve and Wenger (1991) proposed the theory of a community of practice where members come together with a common passion or a need to do something, to learn something. In such a community, learning is enhanced through interactions, encouragement, role models and support. Peer-to-peer learning allows learners to help one another, benefitting both the learners and the tutors (Fuchs, 1997). Best of all, it is scalable to the millons."
- Andreas Link left the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
Rich DeMillo
3:49 PM
right input needed
Matt
3:50 PM
http://www.ewenger.com/
Ashwin Ram
3:50 PM
See slide #11 on the slideshare on this post: http://preetharam.wordpress.com/2011/05/11/open-social-learning-aka-massively-multiplayer-online-learning/
Rich DeMillo
3:50 PM
@georges -- it takes a lot of ideas to innovate
Ashwin Ram
3:51 PM
Communities of Practice + Peer Learning + Social Constructivism + Blended Learning
George S
3:52 PM
the notion of betting on a winner isn't prudent in light of complexity theory
Ashwin Ram
3:52 PM
Also see Siemens & Downes "Connectivism" ideas: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connectivism
George S
3:52 PM
@Rich - you're an optimist!
brainysmurf
3:53 PM
not sure troublemakers are drawn to university setting in the first place?
- Aga P left the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
Matt
3:53 PM
Nietzche found the idea of philosophy within institutions laughable.
- Cathi 1 joined the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
George S
3:54 PM
This is the site Rich referred to: http://gtmooc.com/
Ashwin Ram
3:54 PM
Behaviorism --> Cognitivism --> Constructivism --> Connectivism: http://www.elearnspace.org/Articles/connectivism.htm
George S
3:55 PM
btw, if anyone is interested, Stephen and I just started an open course on this, well, today: http://cck12.mooc.ca/
Preetha
3:55 PM
Good stuff @george and @stephen. Visionary!
brainysmurf
3:55 PM
part of being busy @stephen @george S
institution vs. distribution? may need to ponder this
3:56 PM
to institute = contain, constrain, confine?
3:56 PM
can an institution actually be 'open'
3:57 PM
Matt
3:57 PM
Google, Facebook, Twitter, et al are trying to gain power over us by being the new gatekeepers to knowledge and opportunity.
Massively centralised databases and user data.
3:58 PM
It's unhealthy.
3:58 PM
brainysmurf
3:58 PM
@matt so you don't use any of the 'big' players? Google, FB, Twitter, etc?
Matt
3:59 PM
No, I self host.
siavogel
3:59 PM
To difficult for me @matt
Matt
3:59 PM
Everything runs on my own server.
It's not that hard to do these days.
3:59 PM
siavogel
4:00 PM
Thanks so far.
- joel left the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
brainysmurf
4:00 PM
time on Wed again please?
Matt
4:00 PM
A lot of hosts offer one-click installs for web software.
gjoyce 1
4:00 PM
I work at a univ. This is so relevant, a comprehensive way for me to see all the parts, influences in a together way...fantastic and thank you.
brainysmurf
4:00 PM
thanks all
Preetha
4:00 PM
10 am PT wed, 1pm EST
- Seán Conlan left the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
- Mike McCracken left the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
- George S left the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
- dean florez left the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
- Rohan left the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
- tsei joined the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
- tsei left the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
- Matt #2 joined the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
- Matt #2 left the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
- Asad Choudhary #2 left the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -
- Colm Shalvey left the Main Room. ( 9:37 AM ) -

Comments

Your Comment

You can preview your comment and continue editing until you are satisfied with it. Comment will not be posted on the until you have clicked 'Done'.



Enter email to receive replies: